| 1985-1986 | |
| TEAM TROPHIES | |
| Fellowship Night | |
| Tournament Winners | |
| Jerry Dillinger | Corbly Orndorff |
| Jim Hawkins | Elaine Thompson |
| Larry Mecera | Jeff Weaver |
| John Modrick | Hank Workman, Jr. |
| Charlie Moon | |
| Carlton T. Calvert Memorial Award: | |
| (Awarded to the Team with the most players under age 25) | |
| Jefferson Baptist | |
| League Championship Trophies | |
| 3rd Place: | |
| Waynesburg Methodist | |
| & Waynesburg Christian | |
| 2nd Place: | |
| Greene Valley Presbyterian | |
| League Champion: | |
| Waynesburg Baptist | |